TP Doctor: Administrative services in tax audits and German formal requirements
September 16, 2009
If a German affiliate of a MNE receives administrative services (for example tax, legal and accounting advice) from a foreign holding corporation what formal requirements must be met under German rules? And how do the services provide a benefit for the German company?
German transfer pricing principles usually follow the OECD guidelines, especially the arm's-length principle. However, often specific additional formal requirements have to be fulfilled.
For administrative services the OECD guidelines apply the benefit test to evaluate whether the service provided is beneficial for the recipient and consequently whether under arm's-length circumstances a third party would be willing to pay for it. Therefore, the service must be beneficial for the recipient, should not be provided in duplicate and should not be more than the costs incurred if the service was to be provided or requested locally. Generally, shareholder activities do not qualify as a service. Direct charges are preferred for services provided directly, however in practice indirect allocation methods are often applied for a range of services, using several keys to allocate costs (and an additional arm's-length mark-up).
According to strict German tax (case) law certain formal requirements have to be fulfilled that otherwise at least shift the burden of proof to the taxpayer. These formal requirements are:
A written agreement should be in place that;

Sorry. You must be a subscriber to view this article. Alternatively, why not take a free trial? To subscribe and access this article immediately simply click here or call +44(0)207 779 8380.